PADs for Parkinson’s

Posted June 4, 2017 at 8:12 pm by

Lisa Holt, of San Juan Island Dog Train­ing is work­ing with a team of vol­un­teers to train dogs to “sniff out” Parkin­son’s Dis­ease. They are the first to do this in the Unit­ed States. It all began when news broke sev­er­al years ago of a woman in Scot­land, Joy Milne, who could “smell” Parkin­son’s disease.

Nan­cy Jones, a for­mer stu­dent of Lisa’s heard about that and took Lisa to lunch where they brain­stormed the idea of dogs doing the same thing, and Parkin­son’s Alert Dogs (PADs) was born.

Read the full sto­ry below for more. And be sure to click on the video above.

PADs for Parkinson’s.

by Lisa Holt -

Canine com­pan­ions are a part of the fab­ric of life on San Juan Island, a fab­ric that is woven from the Island’s nat­ur­al beau­ty, the com­bined and eclec­tic skillsets of the var­ied back­grounds of its inhab­i­tants, and quite a lot of dog hair. A dog or two, or some­times three of four, can be found in the homes, on the couch­es, and in the hearts of over half of the Island’s 7000 res­i­dents. Thir­ty per­cent of these dog-own­ing res­i­dents are over the age of 65, and like­ly to be retired. More than half of Island dog-own­ers have long since cel­e­brat­ed their 40th birth­day. Here, we have peo­ple with time to ded­i­cate to the care, exer­cise, and train­ing of their dogs.

Lisa Holt, a cer­ti­fied dog train­er on the Island, has worked with many of these dogs and their own­ers for the past 10 years. In 2011, she became inter­est­ed and enthused by the sport of detec­tion train­ing. The fol­low­ing year, she pur­sued and obtained her cer­ti­fi­ca­tion in K9 Nose Work detec­tion from the Nation­al Asso­ci­a­tion of Canine Scent Work. As part of her con­tin­u­ing edu­ca­tion, she invest­ed hun­dreds of off-island hours attend­ing work­shops and work­ing her own dog under the tute­lage of var­i­ous pro­fes­sion­al­ly-acclaimed detec­tion train­ers, includ­ing Fred Helfers, Amy Herot, Ron Gaunt, Jill O’Brien, and Gail McCarthy. Lisa also worked in the field of Dia­betes Alert Train­ing and ADHD assis­tance dog train­ing, and has now trained Island dogs for these spe­cial­ized ser­vice and detec­tion pur­pos­es. On the Island, she offers detec­tion train­ing for com­pan­ion dogs, an activ­i­ty known as K9 Nose Work, and has had over 100 Island stu­dents com­plete her detec­tion train­ing classes.

This brings us to the very start of PADs. One of Lisa’s many stu­dents was long-time Island res­i­dent, Nan­cy Jones, who, along with her hus­band, David Jones, took Lisa’s entry-lev­el detec­tion train­ing class with their canine com­pan­ion, Bren­na. This was dur­ing the sum­mer of 2015. Nan­cy worked Bren­na in class while her hus­band, David, sat, watched and nod­ded at Brenna’s progress in Nose Work. David most cer­tain­ly would have been work­ing Bren­na had it not been for Parkinson’s Dis­ease. At that time, David had been strug­gling with Parkinson’s for over 15 years. This for­mer may­or, fire fight­er and naval offi­cer was now some­one who required assis­tance to sim­ply get in and out of a chair.

Then, in Octo­ber of 2015, the media released a piece of news that sparked the atten­tion of the Parkinson’s com­mu­ni­ty of researchers, care­givers, patients and their fam­i­lies. It was report­ed that a woman in Scot­land, Joy Milne, could “smell” Parkinson’s. Joy Milne, a for­mer nurse, said that peo­ple with Parkinson’s had a musty scent, and that she noticed this on her own hus­band, who was diag­nosed with the dis­ease. Researchers at the Uni­ver­si­ty of Edin­burgh decid­ed to test her with a series of 12 shirts, six of which were from Parkinson’s patients. Ms. Milne cor­rect­ly iden­ti­fied the six shirts, and then a sev­enth shirt, as well. Months lat­er, the own­er of the sev­enth shirt was diag­nosed with Parkinson’s. Why was this impor­tant news? Parkinson’s is a dis­ease with no defin­i­tive diag­no­sis, espe­cial­ly in ear­ly stages. It is report­ed that of the 10 mil­lion peo­ple with Parkinson’s, about 20% of Parkinson’s patients are mis­di­ag­nosed. But that’s not all. If Parkinson’s could be detect­ed a mere 5 years before the tell­tale signs of tremors and shak­i­ness, a patient could poten­tial­ly lead sev­er­al decades of nor­mal life. David Jones would have been work­ing his dog in Lisa’s detec­tion class.

With­in days of the Joy Milne news release, Nan­cy Jones con­tact­ed Lisa Holt and invit­ed her to lunch. The top­ic was all snif­fer dogs and Parkinson’s. If a woman in Scot­land could smell Parkinson’s, what could this mean in terms of dogs? Dogs pos­sess an extra­or­di­nary sense of smell, with a demon­strat­ed low­er lim­it of detec­tion at con­cen­tra­tions of one part per tril­lion, which is three orders of mag­ni­tude more sen­si­tive than avail­able lab­o­ra­to­ry test­ing instru­ments. Dogs can detect, asso­ciate and sort oder­ant mol­e­cules, or volatile organ­ic com­pounds, in parts per mil­lion. Their olfac­to­ry sys­tem allows dogs to detect pathogens, cadav­ers, bio­log­i­cal tar­gets, nar­cotics, gas­es, ele­ments, microbes, accel­er­ant and explo­sive com­pounds, and many oth­er odors, unde­tectable by humans.

The idea of test­ing dogs to see if they could sniff out Parkinson’s was excit­ing. But sure­ly, some­one else was already going down this path? It didn’t make sense to under­take a mon­u­men­tal research quest that had already been called and answered. Lisa tapped the detec­tion com­mu­ni­ty, Nan­cy reached out to the Parkinson’s com­mu­ni­ty, and Google was exten­sive­ly queried. In Jan­u­ary of 2016, Lisa and Nan­cy had their answer. No one was work­ing on train­ing dogs to detect Parkinson’s. In ear­ly Feb­ru­ary, these two Island women, brought togeth­er by dogs and dis­ease, part­nered to start the first pilot project to deter­mine whether dogs could detect Parkinson’s disease.

Eight of Lisa’s K9 Nose Work stu­dents stepped up and vol­un­teered their high­ly-dri­ven dogs for the project. A mobile home was saved from demo­li­tion and repur­posed for the project. A bio­chemist and research sci­en­tist was recruit­ed to help with research pro­to­col. A med­ical physi­cian was recruit­ed to help with med­ical con­sul­ta­tion. Vol­un­teer scribes were enlist­ed to pro­vide watch­ful doc­u­men­ta­tion. Parkinson’s patients were con­tact­ed and enrolled as sam­ple donors. Non-Parkinson’s donors were recruit­ed to pro­vide con­trol sam­ples. T‑shirts, dis­pos­able gloves, and air­tight stain­less-steel can­is­ters were pur­chased. Donor kits were assem­bled. Research track­ing forms were print­ed. On March 10, 2016, the eight dogs, recruit­ed for the project, stepped sep­a­rate­ly through the doors of the trail­er to sniff their first round.

By May 11, 2016, six of the eight dogs remained in the study. These six were used for final test­ing. At this point, the Super Six had worked approx­i­mate­ly 52 indi­vid­ual days, had sniffed over 200 rounds, and had been exposed on at least 800 times to Parkinson’s Dis­ease, using 15 unique PD donors and 30 unique non-PD (con­trol) donors. For final test­ing, the dogs would be intro­duced to three new, unique Parkinson’s Donors, and two addi­tion­al Parkinson’s donors that were intro­duced very ear­ly in the study, dur­ing ini­tial pair­ing. Pair­ing is a stage where the dogs’ pri­ma­ry reward is paired with the scent. At approx­i­mate­ly 400 expo­sures, the pri­ma­ry reward was removed, and the dog is intro­duced to only the Parkinson’s scent.

At the com­ple­tion of the final test­ing on May 19, the results were inspir­ing. On Can­is­ter Num­ber 32 (PD Patient not on drugs) the dogs affirmed PD at the rate of 96% cor­rect. On Can­is­ter Num­ber 34 (PD Patient not on drugs) the dogs affirmed PD at the rate of 98% cor­rect. On Can­is­ter Num­ber 8B (PD Patient on drug) the dogs affirmed PD at the rate of 97% cor­rect. On Can­is­ter 12C (PD Patient on drug) the dogs affirmed PD at the rate of 87%. On Can­is­ter 30 (PD Patient on drug) the dogs affirmed PD at 9%. Lat­er on, we were informed that this patient (#30) was re-diag­nosed with tremor dis­or­der. These tests were inde­pen­dent­ly con­duct­ed with all unique human con­trols in the room.

This was a high-five day for the study. The dogs had worked 3 com­plete­ly unknown donors with unknown human con­trols and had cor­rect­ly alert­ed. We called this stage Phase 1, because now, armed with results from Phase 1, we had Phase 2 firm­ly in our sights.

Phase 1 referred to a dis­cov­ery peri­od of whether dogs could detect Parkinson’s Dis­ease. Phase 2 was planned with the goal of train­ing dogs to detect Parkinson’s Dis­ease, estab­lish­ing train­ing pro­to­col for oth­er train­ers, and mak­ing our research find­ings avail­able for oth­er researchers to draw upon.

Ambi­tious indeed.

Phase 2 kicked off in Sep­tem­ber of 2016. PADs for Parkinson’s became a more for­mal orga­ni­za­tion. A 501C3 was filed and grant­ed. More dogs were recruit­ed for the pro­gram. A Board of Direc­tors was formed. Grant requests were sub­mit­ted. The trail­er was secured as a train­ing facil­i­ty for a few more months. A hun­dred T‑shirts and can­is­ters were pur­chased. A brochure was print­ed. The media pub­lished results. We received requests from around the world from patients want­i­ng the dogs to test their T‑shirt. Parkinson’s Dis­ease Sup­port Groups were con­tact­ed for donor sam­ples. Car­ing and giv­ing Islanders sent checks. Some for $10. Some for $25. Some for hun­dreds. Pad­dle for Parkinson’s gave thou­sands, along with the Com­mu­ni­ty Foun­da­tion and the CF Women’s Fund.

In ear­ly Feb­ru­ary of 2017, we intro­duced six new dogs to the pro­gram and retained three of our Stage 1 dogs for a total of nine dogs in the pro­gram. A crit­i­cal com­po­nent to the suc­cess of the pro­gram is main­tain­ing a high num­ber of dogs. For test­ing pur­pos­es, it’s impor­tant that as many as eight of every 10 dogs indi­cate a pos­i­tive response to PD for sol­id research. Dogs are not entire­ly reli­able as a sin­gle source, but as a group, the per­cent­age of reli­a­bil­i­ty increas­es by the num­bers in the group.

In March of 2017, anoth­er piece of sub­stan­ti­at­ing news came across the wire from across the Atlantic. The Uni­ver­si­ty of Edin­burgh pro­vid­ed a fol­low-up on the Joy Milne sto­ry. The “smell,” was com­ing from shirts, most notice­ably from the back and the neck area. The source, the researchers con­clud­ed, was sebum. Excret­ed by the seba­ceous glands, this waxy, oily sub­stance is made of triglyc­erides, wax esters, squa­lene, and metabo­lites of fat-pro­duc­ing cells. Chemists report that 9000 mol­e­cules make up a Sebum smear. For PADs, this was good news, because sebum is very much com­prised of volatile organ­ic com­pounds, and these oder­ant mol­e­cules are nice­ly trapped by cot­ton fab­ric. Since numer­ous research stud­ies point to changes in the seba­ceous glands in Parkinson’s patients, it was mak­ing sense that the dogs could iden­ti­fy a PD mark­er by sniff­ing sebum on the shirts. Based on this piece of infor­ma­tion, we began using just the neck and back area of the shirts as sam­ples for the dogs to sniff, thus reduc­ing some of the “back­ground noise,” or added mol­e­c­u­lar dis­trac­tion for the dogs to sort.

Today, June 3, as this sto­ry is being writ­ten, the nine dogs in the pro­gram are show­ing us their evo­lu­tion­ary supe­ri­or­i­ty in spades. The first year dogs (Phase 2) have now worked between 40 and 50 days, over 150 rounds, received more than 600 expo­sures, and worked more than 30 unique Parkinson’s Donor sam­ples and the same num­ber of con­trols. The sec­ond year dogs (start­ed in Phase 1) have now worked more than 100 indi­vid­ual days, over 400 rounds, have more than 1500 expo­sures, and have worked more than 50 unique Parkinson’s Donor sam­ples. As a col­lec­tive group, (first and sec­ond year dogs togeth­er) the dogs have been between 80% and 96% for 10 of the last 11 days.

Look­ing ahead, our great hope and goal is to secure enough fund­ing to pro­vide a group of dogs suit­able for test­ing peo­ple ques­tion­ing or won­der­ing about Parkinson’s. PADs main­tains a list of these peo­ple, and the list is grow­ing long. Too long. In May, we were asked to present the PADs Pro­gram to the Island Rotary Club, a group who asked thought­ful and insight­ful ques­tions. We sim­ply didn’t have time to call on all the hands going up in the room. How­ev­er, in clos­ing, I was quite struck by one of the ques­tions, and I sus­pect it might be one of the Ele­phants in the Room…the ques­tion: “How do you plan to test for ear­ly diag­no­sis of Parkinson’s…are you going to do some sort of gen­er­al screen­ing of the entire population…however would you do that?”

Love­ly ques­tion. There are five ear­ly warn­ing signs. When you pro­vide infor­ma­tion on a med­ical intake form, you are asked to check off over a hun­dred symp­toms that you may or may not expe­ri­ence. If you were to select or indi­cate the five symp­toms relat­ed to PD, your physi­cian may note this, but since there is no ear­ly detec­tion screen­ing tool, your physi­cian is like­ly to sim­ply be on the watch for more sig­nif­i­cant symp­toms, and then if these appear, refer you to a neu­rol­o­gist. How­ev­er, if PD could be sug­gest­ed and treat­ed at this ear­ly stage, then a patient could poten­tial­ly lead as many as three decades of near­ly nor­mal lifestyle. This is the hope and promise that keeps us Padding Forward.

Fac­toids:

Today, every per­son who works in PADs is a vol­un­teer. There are no paid people.

Count­ing donors, we have more than 100 vol­un­teers in PADs.

Han­dler vol­un­teers bring their dogs 4 days a week to train­ing. Week after week.

Train­ing is ongo­ing. There are breaks every 6–8 weeks, but this is a huge com­mit­ment for the handlers.

The dogs are all com­pan­ion dogs. Our nine dogs are of the fol­low­ing breeds, gold­en retriev­er, bor­der col­lie, Aus­tralian shep­herd, vizs­la, gold­en doo­dle, stan­dard poo­dle, Labrador retriev­er, nova sco­tia duck-tolling retriever

The dogs range in age from 8 months to 12 years.

All dogs can do this kind of work. It depends pri­mar­i­ly on the dri­ve of the dog. Dogs with high dri­ve and demon­strate and abil­i­ty to work inde­pen­dent­ly are more like­ly to work through the pres­sure and solve the problem.

Ulti­mate­ly the dogs are search­ing a volatilome, (or scent sig­na­ture) which rep­re­sents a sig­na­ture group of volatile mol­e­cules that need to be present for the dog to iden­ti­fy the mark­er. For exam­ple, in some forms of can­cer, it is sus­pect­ed that there are six sep­a­rate mol­e­cules that the dogs are iden­ti­fy­ing to indi­cate a pos­i­tive for can­cer. For PD, this num­ber remains an unknown.

60,000 Amer­i­cans are diag­nosed with PD each year. 90% are over the age of 50. Over 70% of PD patients are male.

Ref­er­ences and notes:

  1. Fron­tiers in Vet­eri­nary Sci­ence, Canine Detec­tion of the Volatilome: A Review of Impli­ca­tions for Pathogen and Dis­ease Detection
  2. Parkinson’s Dis­ease Foun­da­tion, Sta­tis­tics on Parkinson’s Disease
  3. Sun­day Express, UK, Update March 2017
  4. Wash­ing­ton Post.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2015/10/23/Scottish-woman-detects-a-musky-smell
  5. PD Com­mu­ni­ty Blog, Fri­day, Octo­ber 30, 2015
  6. PADs for Parkinson’s (Parkinson’s Alert Dogs for the pur­pose of ear­ly detec­tion of Parkinson’s)

Board Mem­bers: Karin Agos­ta, Pres­i­dent; Nan­cy Jones, Vice Pres­i­dent; Katy Barsami­an, Sec­re­tary; Car­olyn Hau­gen, Treasurer

Lisa Holt, Pro­gram Direc­tion, Cer­ti­fied Nose Work Instruc­tor, Ani­mal Behav­ior Cer­ti­fied Train­er, Ani­mal Behav­ior Cer­ti­fied Men­tor Train­er, Cer­ti­fied Amer­i­can Treib­ball Trainer

Key Vol­un­teers: Suzanne Bryn­er, Asso­ciate Nose Work Instruc­tor and Jean Don­ald­son, Junior Lev­el stu­dent Acad­e­my for Dog Trainers

Alexan­der Swalling, Ani­mal Behav­ior Cer­ti­fied Train­ing Stu­dent, Dog Sitter

Dogs and Handlers:

  • Bir­git Kri­ete with Jess and Brinkley
  • Judith Okulitch and Tim Kopet with Hudson
  • Katy Barsami­an with Ella
  • Car­olyn Hau­gen with Rowan
  • Karin Agos­ta with Ajax (Han­dled by Karin, owned by Judy Chovan and Bob Stavers)
  • Hol­ly Har­bers with Topper
  • Ann Har­ris with Quil
  • Bar­bara Wright with Mia

A big shout out to our many sam­ple donors and mon­e­tary contributors.

You can support the San Juan Update by doing business with our loyal advertisers, and by making a one-time contribution or a recurring donation.

3 comments...

  1. Hel­lo. I read your arti­cle with inter­est and watched the tv clip.
    I am so inter­est­ed in this pro­gram. I have Parkin­son’s. I have a Papi­lon dog. Is there such a pro­gram near me.…I live in Per­ry KS and what is the cost?
    Thank you.

    Comment by Patty Oliver on July 29, 2017 at 5:59 am
  2. Hel­lo. I read your arti­cle with inter­est and watched the tv clip.
    I am so inter­est­ed in this pro­gram. I have Parkin­son’s. I have a Papi­lon dog. Is there such a pro­gram near me.…I live in Per­ry KS and what is the cost?
    Thank you.

    Comment by Patty Oliver on July 29, 2017 at 6:02 am
  3. Your pro­gram is so impres­sive. Lisa Holt was very impres­sive saw the news article.
    What oppru­tu­ni­ties are there to par­tic­i­pate besides monetarily?
    Would love to be able to work with a dog in the detec­tion process when you expand your pro­gram. Long time pet own­er and have had work­ing (live­stock) dogs. Not real fan­cy ones but ones who could do their jobs well. I am locat­ed in Cen­tral CA.
    If this is a pos­si­ble in the future I would be will­ing to trav­el to WA for training.
    Thank you for your time
    Margaret

    Comment by Margaret on July 29, 2017 at 12:34 pm

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

By submitting a comment you grant the San Juan Update a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. Inappropriate, irrelevant and contentious comments may not be published at an admin's discretion. Your email is used for verification purposes only, it will never be shared.

Receive new post updates: Entries (RSS)
Receive followup comments updates: RSS 2.0