The Old Military Road

Posted June 25, 2020 at 11:40 am by

This arti­cle was writ­ten by Mike Vouri, local author and for­mer NPS Historian…

The heat was already sti­fling at 11 a.m. in late July 2004 when I encoun­tered four Cana­di­an reen­ac­tor col­leagues tak­ing a breather in the shade at the cor­ner of Lit­tle and Dou­glas roads.

Clad in the scar­let and blue wool uni­forms of the mid-19th cen­tu­ry Roy­al Marines, they were run­ning sweat and still had more than nine miles to go on grid­dle-hot pave­ment before they reached Eng­lish Camp. Their object was to high­light the fes­tiv­i­ties of our annu­al Encamp­ment event by rough­ly dupli­cat­ing the route that ran about 13 miles between the British and Amer­i­can gar­risons dur­ing the joint mil­i­tary occu­pa­tion of the island.

It was on this “mil­i­tary road” that sol­diers and marines in the 1860s would have marched en masse for sim­i­lar cel­e­bra­tions, and most impor­tant­ly, on which mes­sen­gers would have car­ried vital dis­patch­es by wag­on or horse­back. The road also pro­vid­ed a trunk line, as it were, that tied one end of the island with the oth­er and accom­mo­dat­ed Euro­pean set­tle­ment. This is a key ele­ment of island his­to­ry and, to our Cana­di­an friends, a sto­ry wor­thy of preser­va­tion, even if they were slap­ping leather on coun­ty roads rather than the orig­i­nal path.

As with the South Beach Trail on the Amer­i­can Camp prairie, the Mil­i­tary Road fol­lowed the lines of least resis­tance as it diag­o­nal­ly spanned the island, cut­ting through for­est, cross­ing prairies and push­ing through the hills, from the Cat­tle Point penin­su­la to West­cott Creek (now Gar­ri­son Bay). How­ev­er, the road was not born in a vac­u­um; that is, the respec­tive offi­cers did not sim­ply take a straight edge and draw a line between the points. Instead, they select­ed a cen­tral path from which a web of foot and stock trails—some undoubt­ed­ly blazed by indige­nous peoples—led to a net­work of graz­ing lands occu­pied by the Hudson’s Bay Company’s Belle Vue Sheep Farm.

Sir James Douglas

The farm was found­ed in Decem­ber 1853 to affirm British pos­ses­sion of the San Juans, which had been in dis­pute since the sign­ing of Treaty of Ore­gon in June of 1846. After land­ing 1,369 head of sheep at Cat­tle Point, Chief Trad­er Charles Griffin—with an able assist from Chief Fac­tor and Van­cou­ver Island Gov­er­nor James Douglas—spent the win­ter build­ing the Home prairie facil­i­ty at what is now Amer­i­can Camp. By April 1854, with an eye on expand­ing the flocks and turn­ing a prof­it, Dou­glas, Grif­fin and their employ­ees led crews of Cowichan and Skag­it Indi­ans in clear­ing sheep runs to the adjoin­ing prairies.

There­after, as the sea­sons unfold­ed, they sliced through for­est and thick­et, bridged creeks and laid cor­duroy (log) roads over swampy areas until, as Dou­glas wrote in a Decem­ber 1855 dispatch:

“Upwards of 2300 head of hors­es, cat­tle and sheep, are now rang­ing over that Island; a large extent of land is under cul­ti­va­tion, and roads have been cut through the for­est near­ly from end to end of the Island.…Thus has been accom­plished, at a great expense, an enter­prise of which no pri­vate per­sons would will­ing­ly incur the risk.” (This was in jus­ti­fi­ca­tion of his unau­tho­rized cor­po­rate takeover of the island.)

Grif­fin was raised in Mon­tre­al, there­fore in his offi­cial journals—ably tran­scribed and inter­pret­ed for the Nation­al Park Ser­vice by San Juan Island his­to­ri­an Boyd Pratt—the wood­land north of today’s Amer­i­can Camp Road is the Grande Bois (Great For­est); a sea­son­al creek, run­ning from The Oaks to Grif­fin Bay, is called Riv­iere Cas­tor (Beaver Riv­er); and a pass through the hills divid­ing San Juan Val­ley from Cat­tle Point Road is Port L’Enfer (The Hell Gate), lat­er Angli­cized to Port­land Fair.

Even­tu­al­ly as many as 10 sheep stations—each with a hut and cor­ral— dot­ted the island from stem to stern, bear­ing names such as First Prairie (Frazier’s farm), Win­ter Sta­tion (the grav­el pit south of Fri­day Har­bor, once known as Bald Hill), Blake’s Sta­tion (Lit­tle Moun­tain in San Juan Val­ley) and Lime­stone Sta­tion (the slopes of today’s Lime­stone Point State Park). Roy­al Navy sur­vey­or, Cap­tain George Richards, named Friday’s Bay (now Fri­day Har­bor) for the shep­herd at Chandler’s Sta­tion, which was locat­ed on a hill above today’s Uni­ver­si­ty of Wash­ing­ton Fri­day Har­bor Laboratories.

At six-foot-five, and eas­i­ly more than 250 pounds (18 stone), James Dou­glas was a big man, and, hold­ing the two top jobs besides in the British colony, was used to hav­ing his way. But no mat­ter how much he bul­lied his adver­saries (for­eign­ers and coun­try­men alike) he could not stop Amer­i­cans from inhab­it­ing San Juan Island, which near­ly led to war. Con­se­quent­ly, in the wake of the Pig War cri­sis of 1859, Dou­glas had to sit back and watch as mil­i­tary forces adapt­ed his sheep trails into a clas­sic fron­tier “mil­i­tary road.”

Mil­i­tary roads are as old as the first armies march­ing between Zig­gu­rats in ancient Mesopotamia and as late as Dwight Eisenhower’s inter­state high­way sys­tem. That’s right, the next time you take that lit­tle jog on I‑5 on your way to Cost­co, remem­ber that road net­work was designed not only to stim­u­late com­merce, but to speed troops, com­mu­ni­ca­tions and materiel rapid­ly and effi­cient­ly between far-flung points. In addi­tion to not­ing the effec­tive­ness Germany’s auto­bahns dur­ing World War II, Ike undoubt­ed­ly stud­ied the Romans at West Point. All 50,000 miles of their roads were cut by and for the legions as I learned while hik­ing one of them last sum­mer below Hadrian’s Wall in north­ern England.

Built at first to haul sup­plies by wag­on to advanced army posts, Amer­i­can mil­i­tary roads were often “the only means of com­mu­ni­ca­tion between out­ly­ing towns” as the fron­tier marched to the Pacif­ic, wrote West Point engi­neer­ing instruc­tor, Pro­fes­sor P.S. Michie. I near­ly missed this point while perus­ing his 1893–94 report to the 53rd Con­gress, as he opened his trea­tise by lit­er­al­ly back­ing into his sub­ject: “With regard to the sub­ject of mil­i­tary roads and bridges from an Amer­i­can standpoint…I am at a loss to find any­thing of inter­est to say, whether new or old…(as) we have nev­er had any mil­i­tary roads in this country…”

For­tu­nate­ly, I read on.

Wash­ing­ton Ter­ri­to­ry was prepped for set­tle­ment begin­ning in 1853 when Lieu­tenant George McClel­lan, West Point class of 1846, arrived to sur­vey and build an immi­grant road from Wal­la Wal­la to Ft. Steila­coom. But in a pre­view of his lat­er per­for­mance as a Civ­il War gen­er­al, he talked a bet­ter game than he played and slinked out of Puget Sound with noth­ing gained from the $20,000 he was issued for the work. His class­mate, Lieu­tenant George Der­by, did much bet­ter four years lat­er com­plet­ing a wag­on road from Fort Van­cou­ver to The Dalles.

George Pickett

Grad­u­at­ing near the top the class, Der­by and McClel­lan had earned the prized assign­ment to the Com­pa­ny of Engi­neers, based at the acad­e­my. Anoth­er class­mate in the ter­ri­to­ry, Cap­tain George E. Pick­ett, grad­u­at­ed dead last. This may be why a con­tract engi­neer was engaged in August 1856 to help him build a mil­i­tary road from his new­ly estab­lished Fort Belling­ham to the Vil­lage of What­com, three and half miles away. Rough­ly antic­i­pat­ing Marine Dri­ve, which runs along Belling­ham Bay, the road end­ed in a bridge over What­com Creek. A replace­ment built down­stream and named for Pick­ett in 1918 was stripped of the name last fall by the Belling­ham City Coun­cil because Pick­ett fought for the Confederacy.

Pick­ett first came to San Juan Island in July 1859 in time to help ignite the Pig War cri­sis, but was then ordered back to Fort Belling­ham (at the urg­ing of Dou­glas) in Decem­ber and did not return until the fol­low­ing April. His sec­ond land­ing, com­bined with the Roy­al Marines’ arrival on West­cott Creek the month before, meant that two sea­soned “com­mu­ni­ty builders” were in com­mand on the island. Marine Cap­tain George Bazalgette’s detach­ment had been part of the con­tin­gent that helped the Roy­al Engi­neers build New West­min­ster, B.C.

Why the marine camp was sit­ed so far away from Pickett’s camp remains sub­ject to inter­pre­ta­tion, as time and dis­tance con­tributed to the mis­com­mu­ni­ca­tion that char­ac­ter­ized the Pig War cri­sis. Roy­al Navy Cap­tain James Pre­vost of H.M.S. Satel­lite, who was assigned this task, evi­dent­ly was sold on the site by his third lieu­tenant, Richard Roche (for all you new­com­ers, pro­nounced ROACH as in clip or pest, not a Parisian per­fume), who extolled the shel­tered bay and abun­dance of fresh water. Pre­vost also liked Friday’s Bay, but odd­ly thought it was too far away from the Amer­i­cans, which was a source of amuse­ment for Lieu­tenant Richard Mayne of H.M.S. Plumper:

“…(the marines) are to live in camp on the north end of the Island, near Wescote (sic) creek…sticking them at the oppo­site end of the Island as if they were to eat each other.”

Actu­al­ly, the lads and Yanks pre­ferred mut­ton and veni­son to fuel their labors, which the gar­risons com­menced almost imme­di­ate­ly, work­ing in both direc­tions over the well-trod sheep runs. The let­ter books of both camps are sketchy on the con­struc­tion details, though one can imag­ine them clear­ing glacial errat­ics, log­ging old-growth Dou­glas firs and stack­ing rocks to sup­port the right-of way along hill­sides. Pick­ett req­ui­si­tioned trusty army mules instead of hors­es to han­dle this mixed terrain.

What we know of the route comes from maps drawn of both camps, the Amer­i­cans’ first iter­a­tion com­plet­ed in 1860 by Lieu­tenant Thomas Casey, an engi­neer­ing offi­cer from Fort Steila­coom (who would go on to fin­ish the Wash­ing­ton Mon­u­ment and over­see the con­struc­tion of the Library of Con­gress). The camp roads were fur­ther clar­i­fied in a copy of the map lat­er ren­dered by Lieu­tenant James Forsyth, Pickett’s sec­ond in com­mand. Eng­lish Camp’s road net­work was not chart­ed until U.S. Army Major Nathaniel Mich­ler sur­veyed the area in 1874 fol­low­ing the end of the joint occupation.

But our best peri­od view of the route was born of the very con­tro­ver­sy it was designed to resolve after two Amer­i­cans in Novem­ber 1860 were caught by the marines doing a test exca­va­tion of lime­stone at Roche Har­bor. The marines insist­ed that the future quar­ry site was part of Eng­lish Camp, which prompt­ed the two gov­ern­ments to order Pick­ett and Bazal­gette to redraw their camp bound­aries. The marine com­man­der deliv­ered his ver­sion of the map in May 1861 (a month before Pick­ett resigned his com­mis­sion), which includ­ed a sketch of the com­plete Mil­i­tary Road. As crude as it may be, the map reveals a track that, in addi­tion to show­ing gen­er­ous­ly extend­ed reser­va­tions, has the road cut­ting across San Juan Val­ley and climb­ing over the cen­tral hills to West Val­ley and Gar­ri­son Bay.

Our next view did not come until after the bound­ary dis­pute was set­tled in the Unit­ed States’ favor when a sur­vey was con­duct­ed by the U.S. Gov­ern­ment Land Office in 1874–76. When the island was for­mal­ly divid­ed into town­ships and the land auc­tioned off the Mil­i­tary Road was sud­den­ly cross­ing pri­vate prop­er­ty, where traces may be found today.

Those wish­ing to relive the days of yore with­out tres­pass­ing can walk an approx­i­mate track that begins behind the Amer­i­can Camp vis­i­tor cen­ter and push­es up the Fraz­er Home­stead trail between the park bound­ary and Rosler Road. At Eng­lish Camp you can view a 50-yard stretch behind the Sand­with orchard at the south end of the park that Mich­ler labeled “Road to San Juan City.” Or bush­whack your way through a spur, far­ther east, that ter­mi­nates on a rocky shelf in the Mitchell Hill trail net­work. This path he described as an “Unfin­ished Gov­ern­ment Road.” No one real­ly knows why or for what pur­pose this route was attempted.

How­ev­er, what we do know is that, because of the road, peace was main­tained through­out the joint mil­i­tary occu­pa­tion despite lime con­tro­ver­sies, whisky sell­ers, smug­glers, claim jumpers and innu­mer­able oth­er inci­dents that could have incit­ed inter­na­tion­al tensions.

And this was a fit­ting thing for our Cana­di­an friends to cel­e­brate, despite their exhaustion.

To learn more about the joint occu­pa­tion and plans to devel­op an Old Mil­i­tary Road Trail, visit:

You can support the San Juan Update by doing business with our loyal advertisers, and by making a one-time contribution or a recurring donation.


Categories: History

No comments yet. Be the first!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

By submitting a comment you grant the San Juan Update a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. Inappropriate, irrelevant and contentious comments may not be published at an admin's discretion. Your email is used for verification purposes only, it will never be shared.

Receive new post updates: Entries (RSS)
Receive followup comments updates: RSS 2.0